Amazon's Choice

REVLON Super Lustrous Creamy Lipstick, Toast of New York Review 2026: Is it Worth It?

4.4
35,772
200+ Bought last month
Current Price $14.49
REVLON Super Lustrous Creamy Lipstick, Toast of New York
7.8
Expert Score

Quick Analysis Verdict

"Best for shoppers who want an affordable, creamy, highly pigmented everyday lipstick with moisturizing feel; not for those who need transfer‑proof, long‑wear color or absolute shade stability."

Value: 8.0/10 Ranked #1 in Makeup
*Prices and availability are accurate as of Nov 20, 17:13 ET and are subject to change.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases

Review Methodology

Why this analysis may help before you buy

4.4

Rating signal

We weigh star rating together with 35,772 visible reviews so a rating is not judged in isolation.

200+

Buyer momentum

Recent purchase activity and category badges help us identify products shoppers are actively considering.

7.8/10

RefreshBuy score

The score combines performance, quality, value, and ease-of-use signals for this category.

Decision Guide

Is REVLON Super Lustrous Creamy Lipstick, Toast of New York a good fit for you?

For shoppers comparing Makeup products, this REVLON option looks strongest on ease of use with a 9.0/10 signal. The main area to double-check is performance, especially if that is your top priority.

Best For

Everyday wearable lipstick for quick, comfortable, hydrating color touch-ups and building a versatile shade collection.

Evidence

very broad review coverage, 4.4/5 rating, and 200+ recent monthly purchases.

Value Read

Value score 8.0/10 at $14.49 current tracked price.

Choose it if

You want a Makeup pick where the strongest measurable signal is ease of use and the current review base is large enough to compare with alternatives.

Compare alternatives if

Your buying decision depends mostly on performance, long-term durability, or a lower final checkout price after marketplace changes.

Before buying

Check both Amazon Canada and Amazon US from this detail page, then compare similar Makeup products below before deciding.

Best Application

Everyday wearable lipstick for quick, comfortable, hydrating color touch-ups and building a versatile shade collection.

Investment Value

Great Value

Durability Index

Moderate — creamy formula and standard plastic tube offer months of regular use; expect the formula to require reapplication frequently and color performance to vary by shade and lip chemistry.

Key Buying Points

✓

80% conditioning ingredients (emollients + vitamins C & E) — delivers noticeably softer, less flaky lips versus matte sticks and reduces tug during application.

✓

Microfine pigments — provides rich, buildable color payoff in one to two swipes for polished looks without heavy layering.

✓

Cream finish and emollient base — visibly minimizes fine lip lines and creates a fuller-looking appearance right after application.

✓

Wide shade range (72 iconic shades) — broad palette increases likelihood of finding flattering undertone matches across skin tones.

✓

Affordable drugstore positioning — offers luxury-feel texture and pigment at a lower price point, making shade‑collection practical.

✓

Smooth application — glide-on formula increases ease-of-use for quick touch-ups and precise lining-free wear.

✓

Vitamins and conditioning complex — helps maintain lip hydration during daily use, reducing the need for frequent balm top-ups.

The Catch

!

Longevity is limited — formula transfers and usually requires reapplication after eating or drinking.

!

Some shades shift on-skin — reviewers report immediate color morphing on certain undertones (e.g., warm shades appearing cooler or brighter).

!

Can emphasize dryness for very chapped lips — despite emollients, the creamy formula can highlight dry patches if lips aren't prepped.

!

Not transfer‑proof — expect transfer to cups/masks and less performance for full-day wear without touch-ups.

!

Packaging and size are basic — standard drugstore tube with no advanced sealing; perceived value depends on individual usage frequency.

Performance Scorecard

Performance 7.0
Quality 7.0
Value 8.0
Ease of use 9.0

Common Questions & Expert Insights

Q: Is this lipstick moisturizing for dry lips? ▼
Yes — the Super Lustrous line is formulated with a high proportion of conditioning ingredients and vitamins to hydrate lips. The product contains an emollient base and conditioning complex (noted in ingredient claims and corroborated by many user reports), so it performs better than standard matte sticks; however, very cracked lips still benefit from pre-application balm or exfoliation for optimal finish.
Q: Will the color stay true on my lips all day? ▼
Often not — some shades can shift on different skin undertones and may not remain identical to the tube color. Multiple user reports show immediate color morphing on certain tones (e.g., Berry Haute appeared brighter/more mauve on some users). Test or sample when possible, especially for mid-to-deep or warm shades.
Q: Is this lipstick long-lasting and transfer-proof? ▼
No — it is not transfer-proof and has limited long-wear performance. The creamy, emollient formula prioritizes comfort and pigment payoff over adhesion; expect transfer with eating/drinking and plan for touch-ups every few hours.
Q: Can I use it with a lip liner for sharper edges? ▼
Yes — it layers well with most lip liners and accepts liner without pilling. The creamy texture allows precise application and blending; for improved longevity, line and fill the lips before applying the lipstick.
Q: Is this suitable if I have sensitive skin or allergies? ▼
Generally yes, but patch testing is recommended for sensitivity-prone users. The formula includes conditioning agents and vitamins, but fragrance or specific additives can irritate a few people; review ingredient list and test before full-face use.
Q: Will it work on very dark or very fair skin tones? ▼
Yes — the broad shade range increases the chance of a suitable match across skin tones. Because pigments are buildable, users with darker or fairer skin can achieve the desired intensity, but undertone differences mean trying samples or multiple swatches is advised.
Q: How do I remove this lipstick effectively? ▼
Oil-based removers or cleansing balms remove it most easily. The creamy, pigment-dense formula comes off cleanly with an oil cleanser; water-only removers may require more effort and could leave a slight tint residue.
Q: Any special storage or shelf-life care? ▼
Store in a cool, dry place and replace if texture or smell changes. As with most emollient lipsticks, avoid prolonged heat exposure (it can soften the stick) and follow standard cosmetic expiration guidance—discard when consistency or scent deviates.
Q: How does this compare to MAC Creamy lipsticks? ▼
Comparable in creaminess and pigment but generally less shade stability and shorter wear than MAC. Revlon delivers similar immediate texture and color payoff at a lower price, while higher-end lines may offer better long-wear formulas and tighter color faithfulness across undertones.
Q: Are there better drugstore alternatives for long wear? ▼
Yes — alternatives exist that prioritize long-wear or transfer resistance over hydration. If long-lasting, transfer-proof performance is your priority, look at drugstore liquid mattes or hybrid formulas; if comfort and moisture are primary, Revlon Super Lustrous remains a leading option.

You May Also Like

Top-rated alternatives in Makeup

View All →